Judith butler s recent contribution to moral philosophy, giving an account of oneself, is a striking counterexample to this trend. In this work, butler returns to the problem of subjectivity and subject formation, but this time in the context of. Giving an account of oneself fordham university press. Judith butler, giving an account of oneself philpapers.
Feb, 2012 antoine choueiry english1111 professor doyle unit 1 final paper a critical analysis of judith butler s giving an account of oneself judith butler s giving an account of oneself discusses the act of giving an account of oneself, taking into consideration the many debatable factors as well as their criticality. Read giving an account of oneself by judith butler, constellations. In her first extended study of moral philosophy, judith butler offers a provocative outl. As she notes very clearly in the beginning of the text, butler is not interested in merely synthesizing ethical traditions, but rather in developing an entirely new. Jun 01, 2008 read giving an account of oneself by judith butler, constellations. In three chapters, the book demonstrates how difficult it is to give an account of oneself, and how this lack of selftransparency and narratibility is crucial to an. Giving an account of oneself by judith butler goodreads. Jewishness and the critique of zionism 2012, and senses of the subject 2015. In her first extended study of moral philosophy, judith butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practiceone responsive to the need for critical autonomy and grounded. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. Giving an account of oneself, judith butlers recent foray into moral philosophy, is a lucid interrogation of the problem of responsibility in the wake of contemporary critiques of the subject. In brilliant dialogue with adorno, levinas, foucault, and other thinkers, she. It explores aspects of risk, justice, narrative limit and a morality of multilingualism in emergent multilingual research frameworks.
Butler takes as her starting point ones ability to answer the questions what. Oct 30, 2005 judith butler is maxine elliot professor of comparative literature and critical theory at the university of california at berkeley. Judith butlers text, giving an account of oneself takes up the question of ethics and the role of narrative retelling of ones story within the context of subjectformation. Project muse giving an account of oneself by judith. Butler writes, i would like to start, and to end, with the question of the human, of who counts as human, and the related question of whose lives count as lives, and with a question that has preoccupied many of us for years. In this work, butler returns to the problem of subjectivity and subject formation, but this time in the context of ethics and ethical philosophy. This is followed by a posthegelian account of recognition that seeks to establish the social basis for giving an account of oneself. In this text, butler mobilizes the work of levinas and laplanche among others to theorise responsibility as stemming from the recognition of. Although the reader will be rewarded by repeated readings of this book, the. Judtith butler is the maxine elliot professor of rhetoric and comparative epub literature at the university of california, berkeley.
Giving an account of oneself judith butler pdf are you looking for ebook giving. More recently, butler has focused on questions of ethics construed, on the one side, as the problem of living life in relation to, but also in excess of normative claims. Giving an account of oneself by judith butler, maxine. In recent years, the critique of poststructuralism, itself loquacious, has held that the postulation of a subject who is not selfgrounding undermines the possibility of respon sibility and, in particular, of giving an account of oneself. Giving an account of oneself by judith butler, maxine elliot. Giving an account of oneself quotes showing 11 of 1 we must recognize that ethics requires us to risk ourselves precisely at moments of unknowingness, when what forms us diverges from what lies before us, when our willingness to become undone in relation to others constitutes our chance of becoming human. Butler takes as her starting point ones ability to answer the questions what have i done. Giving an account of oneself standing seminar in critical theory. Butler, 9780823225040, download free ebooks, download free pdf epub ebook. While referencing much of butler s work, thiem engages most thoroughly with butler s recent book, giving an account of oneself, which is her most explicit theorisation of ethical responsibility to date. Affect did not play an explicit part in butlers analysis throughout giving an account of oneself or precarious life.
Pdf giving an account of oneself download full pdf book. With particular attention to the trajectory of butlers project from the psychic life of power to giving an account of oneself, the article discusses the shortcomings of these two positions and the virtues of the alternative account that butler develops during this period. Giving an account of oneself, judith butler s recent foray into moral philosophy, is a lucid interrogation of the problem of responsibility in the wake of contemporary critiques of the subject. Parts of chapter two appeared as an article entitled giving an account of oneself. Butler offers a critique of the moral self, arguing that the transparent, rational, and continuous ethical subject is an impossible construct that seeks to deny the specificity of what it is to be human. In three powerfully crafted and lucidly written chapters, butler demonstrates how difficult it is to give an account of oneself, and how this lack of selftransparency and. Although the reader will be rewarded by repeated readings of this book, the subtlety of butler s presentation is so seamlessly. Judith butler s giving an account of oneself discusses the act of giving an account of oneself, taking into consideration the many debatable factors as well as their criticality. A place at once more hospitable and more challenging than it has been, less exclusionary and less indifferent than is. Butlers prose is remarkably clear and her arguments are lucid. Because i find that i cannot give an account of myself without accounting for the social conditions under which i emerge, ethical reflection requires a turn to social theory. What does it mean to lead a moral life in her first extended study of moral philosophy, judith butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practiceone responsive to the need for critical autonomy and grounded in a new sense of the human. Antoine choueiry english1111 professor doyle unit 1 final paper a critical analysis of judith butlers giving an account of oneself judith butlers giving an account of oneself discusses the act of giving an account of oneself, taking into consideration the many debatable factors as well as their criticality.
In three powerfully crafted and lucidly written chapters, butler demonstrates how difficult it is to give an account of oneself, and how this lack of selftransparency and narratibility is crucial to an ethical understanding of the human. File type pdf giving an account of oneself judith butler. Judith butler is maxine elliot professor of comparative literature and critical theory at the university of california at berkeley. Best of all, they are entirely free to find, use and download, so there is no cost or stress at all. Access to society journal content varies across our titles. While referencing much of butlers work, thiem engages most thoroughly with butlers recent book, giving an account of oneself, which is her most explicit theorisation of ethical responsibility to date. Giving an account of oneself ebook written by judith butler, maxine elliot professor of rhetoric judith p butler. Judith butlers recent contribution to moral philosophy, giving an account of oneself, is a striking counterexample to this trend.
The power of mourning and violence and undoing gender. A critical analysis of judith butlers giving an account. It then examines foucaults later theory of subject formation and considers the limitations one encounters when one tries to use it to think the other. Military refusers and the invocation of conscience. This essay argues that the theory of confession, even in its most recent elaboration by judith butler in giving an account of oneself 2005, is in need of substantial revision, as the current. Giving an account of oneself 2005 in giving an account of oneself, butler develops an ethics based on the opacity of the subject to itself. Zizek is here reacting to butlers claim, ingiving an account of oneself2005, that the socially determined, partially opaque nature of our subjectivity robs us of autonomy. Throughout butler s piece the thoughts of the three philosophers. Giving an account of oneself by judith butler deepdyve. As the spiritual follow up to her excellent the psychic life of power, giving an account of oneself is perhaps butlers best book to date. Project muse giving an account of oneself by judith butler. If you have access to a journal via a society or association membership, please browse to your society journal, select an article to view, and follow the instructions in this box. A critical analysis of judith butlers giving an account of. Judith butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practiceone responsive to the need for critical autonomy and grounded in a new sense of the human subject.
You will be glad to know that right now giving an account of oneself judith butler pdf is available on our online library. Giving an account of oneself judith butler, maxine elliot. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read giving an. But neither is it only a process that seeks to use judith butlers terms to constrain, subordinate and discipline individual academics. An international journal of critical and democratic theory on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Giving an account of oneself judith butler pdf giving an account of oneself judith butler pdf are you looking for ebook giving an account of oneself judith butler pdf. In her first extended study of moral philosophy, judith butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practiceone responsive to the need for. In her first extended study of moral philosophy, judith butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical. Butler believes that our inability to control the collective symbolic field into which we are insertedalong with our inability to access the murky history of our own formationrenders us partially incomprehensible. For all its theoretical perspicacity and complexity, it is a deeply humane book, a book written by an author with a passionate concern for the human condition and its contemporary travails. In her first extended study of moral philosophy, judith butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practiceon. In her first extended study of moral philosophy, judith butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practiceone responsive to the. It takes as her starting point ones ability to answer the questions what have i done.
Giving an account of oneself quotes by judith butler. In giving an account of oneself, butler opens the question of the very possibility. Butler demonstrates how difficult it is to give an account of oneself, and how this lack of selftransparency and narratibility is crucial to an ethical understanding of the human. With succinctness and clarity, judith butlers giving an account of oneself, delves into the meaning of what it is to put into practice an ethical life. The chapters of judith butler s giving an account of oneself originally were given as the spinoza lectures for the department of philosophy at the university of amsterdam in the spring of 2002.
Review of judith butler s giving an account of oneself. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. In brilliant dialogue with adorno, levinas, foucault, and other thinkers, she eloquently argues the limits, possibilities, and dangers of contemporary ethical thought. Giving an account of oneself a powerful exploration of. The chapters of judith butlers giving an account of oneself originally were given as the spinoza lectures for the department of philosophy at the university of amsterdam in the spring of 2002. Giving an account of oneself by judith butler 803 ratings, 4. I examine butlers continued articulation of a politics and ethics of precariousness, particularly in her most recent book frames of war, and specifically the role of the concept of affect in that text. Butler takes as her starting point ones ability to answer the. Giving an account of oneself judith butler pdf download. Judith butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practiceone responsive to the need for critical autonomy. Although the reader will be rewarded by repeated readings of this book, the subtlety of butlers presentation is so seamlessly. Giving an account of oneself judith butler in recent years, the critique of poststructuralism, itself loquacious, has held that the postulation of a subject who is not selfgrounding undermines the possibility of respon sibility and, in particular, of giving an account of oneself. With our online resources, you can find giving an account of oneself judith butler or just about any type of ebooks, for any type of product. Review judith butler, giving an account of oneself cbs open.
An assessment of butlers ethical subject with the help of ricoeur in giving an account of oneself 2005judith butler investigates the possibility of ethics starting from a poststructuralist subject position. Giving an account of oneself judith butler, maxine. As she notes very clearly in the beginning of the text, butler is not interested in merely synthesizing ethical traditions, but rather in developing an entirely new ethical framework. The book shows that these questions can be answered only by asking.
Drawing on her book, giving an account of oneself 2005, we suggest that the pbrf can also be used to enable and sustain through creating spaces to. Hegel, judith butler and social ontology liz disley, university of cambridge the. Judtith butler is the maxine elliot professor of rhetoric and comparative literature at the university of california, berkeley. Adorno, nietzsche, and foucault, regarding moral philosophy is brought to light, as well as the thoughts of butler herself. Jan 01, 2005 giving an account of oneself ebook written by judith butler, maxine elliot professor of rhetoric judith p butler. Primarily borrowing from theodor adorno, michel foucault, friedrich nietzsche, jean laplanche, adriana cavarero and emmanuel levinas, butler develops a. She is the author of the psychic life of power 1997, antigones claim 2000, giving an account of oneself 2005, parting ways. Download citation giving an account of oneself diacritics 31. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read giving an account of oneself. This book offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practiceone responsive to the need for critical autonomy and grounded in a new sense of the human subject. In her first extended study of moral philosophy, judith butler offers a provocative outline for a new ethical practiceone responsive to the need for critical autonomy and grounded in a new sense of the human subject.
605 192 939 1006 1485 568 291 334 608 50 1269 683 820 466 96 614 1444 1002 173 991 129 28 123 1427 154 1125 1534 707 1407 1524 1472 692 763 366 932 934 1021 980 974 1111 68 263 1105 797 1451 1495 474 721